It's moot at this point, but here's my thoughts.
With NCAA done I am moving on to the cooking game on the Wii, Order Up. If I manage to get a copy of Madden early like I did NCAA I'll get some thoughts up. I am not holding out hope for that. ;)
ANY game that comes with a paper chef's hat -- I'm in. OK, actually, it's a lot of fun to play this with (well, watching) Ashley.